This year’s Oscar nominations were the best and worst of both worlds. The film
Dreamgirls led the pack with eight nominations but did not receive nominations in two categories in which it was considered a shoo-in: Best Director and Best Picture.
It was also a fantastic year for African-American and African actors. A record five acting nominations were presented to this year’s class, which included Forest Whitaker and Will Smith for Best Actor, Jennifer Hudson for Best Supporting Actress and Djimon Hounsou and Eddie Murphy for Best Supporting Actor. Both Whitaker and Hudson are also considered the frontrunners to win in their respective categories.
In addition to its acting nominations,
Dreamgirls received nominations for three songs (“Listen,” “Love You I Do,” and “Patience”), as well as for Costume Design and Sound Mixing. There is a precedent for directors to be passed over, but the snub for Best Picture is a truly puzzling. In addition, Prince, who won a Golden Globe for his song in
Happy Feet, and Aretha Franklin and Mary J. Blige’s passionate anthem, “Never Gonna Break My Faith,” from
Bobby was passed over as well.
With over a month until Oscar night, we examine the major categories.
Best ActorWhitaker’s dazzling, three-dimensional performance as Ugandan dictator Idi Amin left a lasting impression with the Academy's voters. Smith gave an emotional and touching performance in
The Pursuit of Happyness. Leonardo DiCaprio was great in
Blood Diamond. Ryan Gosling’s quietly-effective turn as a drug-addicted teacher in
Half Nelson was moving. And Peter O’Toole gives a heartbreaking performance in a May/December romance in
Venus.
Love To Snub You BabyJamie Foxx will be invited to the party but will have to sit at the small table this year.
Derek Luke did fine work in
Catch A Fire but, unfortunately, he’ll have to wait until next year.
The PretendersO’Toole was touchingly funny in
Venus; Ryan Gosling gave a touching turn as a drug-addicted teacher in
Half Nelson.
The ContendersDiCaprio was recognized for one of his two great performances this year; Smith also gave a career performance.
The Envelope Goes To...Whitaker’s signature performance as Ugandan dictator Idi Amin should win the top prize.
Best ActressIn the most star-studded and predictable category of this year’s Oscar, the usual suspects are represented in all their splendor. British actors Helen Mirren (
The Queen), Judi Dench (
Notes On A Scandal) and Kate Winslet (
Little Children) all were amazing in their respective films. Penelope Cruz reconnects with her family in
Volver, while Meryl Streep receives another nod as the ghastly boss from Hell in
The Devil Wears Prada.
Love To Snub You BabyBeyoncé Knowles was passed over in
Dreamgirls.
Keke Palmer was overlooked for
Akeelah and The Bee, while Sanaa Lathan received the same old treatment for
Something New.
The PretendersBoth Cruz (
Volver) and Winslet (
Little Children) will look lovely on Oscar night, but as Snoop Dogg would say, “That’s That!”
The ContendersStreep and Dench are well-respected, but this is not their year.
The Envelope Goes To...All of the momentum is with Mirren who has been recognized as both Queen Elizabeth I and II.
Best Supporting ActorEddie Murphy finally gets a nomination, 25 years after the beginning of his film career. Hounsou’s supercharged performance garners him a second nomination. Mark Wahlberg stole all of his scenes in
The Departed. Arkin was deviously good in
Little Miss Sunshine, while Jackie Earle Haley was huge in
Little Children.
Love To Snub You BabyJaden Smith was ignored for his performance in
The Pursuit of Happyness. Laurence Fishburne was not recognized for his great work in
Akeelah and the Bee. Chiwetel Ejiofor was solid in two films (
Kinky Boots and
Children of Men) and overlooked.
The PretendersWahlberg, Haley and Hounsou are gearing up for a serious night of networking, just don’t expect to see any of them onstage accepting a trophy.
The ContendersThis is a two-horse race between two sentimental choices. Arkin returns as a nominee after a long absence, but it feels like this could be Murphy’s year.
The Envelope Goes To...Murphy. His first truly dramatic role brings him the Oscar.
Best Supporting ActressJennifer Hudson burst onstage like a supernova, dominating arguably the year’s best film with her powerful vocals in
Dreamgirls. She’ll have to contend with twin nominees from
Babel (Adrianna Barraza and Rinko Kikuchi). Don’t discount sweetheart Abigail Breslin (
Little Miss Sunshine) and the formidable Cate Blanchett, who would be the frontrunner if Hudson were not in this category.
Love To Snub You BabyShareeka Epps was sensational in the little-seen
Half Nelson. Kerry Washington was ignored for her performance in
The Last King of Scotland. The mother of future humanity, Clare-Hope Ashitey, was not recognized in
Children of Men.
The PretendersKikuchi, Barraza and Breslin are all first-time nominees; maybe the second time will be a charm.
The ContendersBlanchett proved that she makes wise choices and is able to execute many different characters.
The Envelope Goes To...Hudson. This Dreamgirl will be an American Idol when her name is called on Oscar night.
Best DirectorWill this finally be Martin Scorsese’s year? Unfortunately for him, his cinematic nemesis, Clint Eastwood, will stare him down again on Oscar night. Paul Greengrass was recognized for his deeply moving
United 93. While both Stephen Frears (
The Queen) and Alejandro Gonzalez Inarritu (
Babel) oversaw complex, yet effective, productions.
Love To Snub You BabyWhat is going to take to get
Spike Lee a nomination?
Inside Man was Lee’s most accessible film to date, featuring a powerhouse cast and, once again, no nomination. Bill Condon,
Dreamgirls' director, successfully adapted a successful Broadway play into an uber-successful film and was passed over. Ask Steven Spielberg about
The Color Purple.
The PretendersGreengrass and Inarritu round out this competitive category.
The ContendersNever discount Eastwood, even though it feels like he won a lot this decade. Also, Frears may prove formidable.
The Envelope Goes To...Scorsese. He gets it, but not for his best film ever (think:
Goodfellas or
Raging Bull.)
Best FilmHollywood kept it all-White again this year, ignoring the obvious choice in
Dreamgirls. The best of the rest include a film about a mole infiltrating a group of Boston mobsters, an embattled family of royals dealing with the death of a princess, one really dysfunctional family traveling cross country to a beauty pageant, a
Crash-esque drama that occurs in separate continents and the long-awaited Japanese side of the Iwo Jima story.
Love To Snub You BabyIn 1985,
The Color Purple received 11 nominations and went home empty handed. Is it better to be shutout on Oscar night or not be invited to the party? It feels awfully strange that
Dreamgirls was the equal of this category’s nominees, and receiving the most nominations, will not be acknowledged as one of the year’s best films.
The PretendersIf Scorsese wins Best Director,
The Departed will not win in this category.
The ContendersAn argument can be made for each of the remaining films. Each has won either major critics’ awards or Golden Globes nominations.
The Envelope Goes To...The call here is either
Babel or
Little Miss Sunshine.
This article also appeared on BET.com